We have 3252 guests and 7 members online

Home > Blogs > Featured Blogs > Plan and Deliver > Maturity Models Miss the Point

Maturity Models Miss the Point
Written by Peter Schuh   
Sunday, 05 April 2009 05:05

Scott Ambler started a minor brouhaha a couple weeks back when he rolled out his first draft of an Agile Process Maturity Model (APMM). I’m not stepping in to evaluate the proposal or the rebuttals because I believe that level of the discussion largely misses the point.

I’d prefer to rebut the whole conversation by reiterating the agile maturity model that I proposed in my book:

  1. The team has decided to start implementing agile development.
  2. The team has successfully implemented its first agile practice and has posted a copy of the Agile Manifesto in inch-high letters on a common wall near the team’s location.
  3. The team has adopted a second practice while collecting metrics and holding review meetings to measure its level of agility.
  4. The team is regularly adopting additional agile practices and actively monitoring its level of agility.
  5. The team has not checked its level of agility for months and is altogether focused on adopting and adapting any practice that will result in better communication, higher quality code, and a system that most accurately meets the needs of the business.

My point? Maturity models are good for selling something, They’re not nearly so useful when your focus is (1) maintaining a healthy team and (2) delivering valuable software. That’s because maturity models simply cannot account for the myriad environmental factors, technical challenges and orgainzational obstacles that teams face. The team that focuses on the characteristics that most directly drive its situation will win out - every time - over a team that evaluates and corrects itself using a borrowed yardstick built from industry standards.

Maturity Models Miss the Point

Read Full Article
Author:Peter Schuh

Comments (0)Add Comment


Write comment

feedShow/hide comment form
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 

Agile Marketplace - Announcements and Special Offers

Rally Software Extends Agile ALM Platform to Meet the Unique Needs of Global Organizations
Rally Unlimited Edition – Promote Agile practices throughout your organization by providing a complete system-of-record of each product's status, progress and quality across the full idea-to-deployment lifecycle. Sign-up today for your free trial!

iPhone iPad Developers Conference
The iPhone iPad Developers Conference, September 27-29 in San Diego, is the world's premier independent event dedicated to building and marketing apps for Apple's iPhone, iPad and iPod Touch. The format includes 45+ technical classes, workshops and breakout classes.  It will also be the first major developer conference after the release of iPhone OS4.  CMC subscribers can receive a $100 discount off the Full Event Passport and/or gain free admission to the exhibits (first time registrants only - cannot be combined with other offers) by inserting the code MEDIASPONSOR when prompted on the eRegistration page linked from www.iphonedevcon.com

AgilePalooza - Serious Learning in a Fun Atmosphere
AgilePaloozas are community events sponsored by VersionOne and Agile Journal.  These one day conferences provide serious learning in a fun atmosphere.   Two tracks are included: Learning Agility and Advancing Agility. Speakers include internationally recognized agile coaches and trainers. The next seminar will be held August 27th in Dallas, TX – use discount code agilejournal and save $20!
Register Here

CollabNet Subversion Edge Improves Governance, Security, Administration
Quickly configure SVN, Apache, and ViewVC with one certified stack, fronted by a powerful UI.
Try our beta version and let us know what you think!